Ando Museum, Naoshima, Kagawa, Japan. Photographed by Yoshihiro Asada.
Mary Guzowski’s fascinating new book – The Art of Architectural Daylighting – reveals how architects have bridged the poetic and practical potential of daylighting to create exquisitely illuminated spaces.
Atmospheric light celebrates the qualities and moods of light to a particular location. This brief case study of ‘Ando Museum’ from The Art of Architectural Daylighting, explains how architect Tadao manipulates light for the desired atmospheric effect.
Ando Museum is located in the historic town of Honmura, Naoshima. During the past thirty years, the island of Naoshima in the Seto Inland Sea of Japan has become an art and architecture destination for visitors from around the world. Over the decades, this quiet island, together with neighbouring islands, Teshima and Inujima, has been transformed by new museums, architecture, and art installations by renowned international artists and Japanese architects to celebrate the beauty of art and nature. Tadao Ando has been involved from the onset, and has designed numerous projects, including the Naoshima International Camp, Benesse House, Art House Project “Minamidera”, Chichu Art Museum, Lee Ufan Museum, and the recent Ando Museum.
Naoshima is nested within the protective shelter of the main islands of Japan, with panoramic views of the surrounding water, mountains, and islands. The humid subtropical climate is predominantly clear, with the exception of the rainy season in summer, which typically lasts from June to mid-July. Located at 33.6° north latitude, the island experiences relatively long hours of daylight throughout the year, ranging from approximately 10 to 14 hours on the winter and summer equinoxes respectively, when the noon-sun altitude varies from a seasonal low of 32.9° to a high of 79.9°. The quality of daylight is soft and indirect during the rainy season, when diffuse daylight enters the building from multiple orientations, while clear skies bring the sunlight’s high contrast, rich colours, and warm solar rays.
Visitors move from the historic streetscape through an entry and into the traditional house to discover a sequence of daylit galleries that culminate in a quiet underground meditation chamber. The small scale and intimate qualities of the site heighten the juxtaposition of the old and new, with spaces progressively transforming from traditional to contemporary in the experience of space, structure, and light. With the exception of the entry area, the Ando Museum relies exclusively on natural light for illumination, with the galleries and meditation chamber brought to life through the changing moods, colours, and movements of daylight.
Ando explains that he sees light as an expression of nature that helps us understand our place within a greater whole.
“I think architecture is a place where one can affirm one’s existence. ... Even in Naoshima, where daylight enters the building from all directions, I want to express how we all live with nature.” Tadao Ando
Light and Design Intentions:
Tadao Ando describes the underlying theme of “invisibility” in the Ando Musueum, where the traditional house is a vessel that contains his contemporary interventions of space, structure, materials, and light. The elements of surprise and discovery are essential to the visitor’s experience of the Ando Museum. It is not until the visitor is deep inside the museum that the new interventions are fully revealed with a dramatic contrast of space and light defined by concrete surfaces and volumes tucked within the traditional timber-frame house.
A geometric clarity and spatial order underlie the organisation of the museum. While Ando is renowned for his exquisite craftsmanship, quality of construction, and refined detailing; he describes his work as a focus on space that is “born of light and geometry”.
The site is divided into four quadrants, with the entry and garden in the southeast, museum entrance in the northeast, main galleries occupying the west half of the site, and the underground meditation chamber beneath the garden. In section, the museum reveals a sequence of nested spaces, with the concrete surfaces and volumes of the new galleries tucked within the traditional timber-frame house. Visitors move through a choreography of spaces that transform from outside to inside, old to new, above to below, and from light to darkness.
Light and Design Strategies:
In the journey from the street into the galleries and underground meditation chamber, visitors transition from connections with the outside neighbourhood to progressively more inwardly focused contemplative spaces. The first view into the museum frames a dramatic vertical space created by the traditional plaster wall to the north and a canted concrete wall to the south. A sequence of three gallery spaces is defined, from the north to south, by sloping and freestanding concrete walls and volumes tucked beneath the traditional timber-frame construction. Daylight is reflected between room and ceiling surfaces to spill over the freestanding concrete walls and through low horizontal slots to adjacent galleries.
Each gallery has a unique luminous quality, with a calm diffuse light in the northern gallery punctuated by abundant illumination in the toplit central gallery, which is contrasted by the quiet shadows and darkness of the southern gallery.
The meditation chamber, accessed through a stairway in the central gallery, is the most intimate, contained, and introspective experience of the journey, as Ando explains: “A slightly tilted concrete cylinder … is buried in the ground as an independent element set apart from the existent building. It contains a space for meditation that is composed solely from the texture of the light that falls into it from above.”
The meditation chamber is constructed of a concrete cylinder with canted walls that are illuminated indirectly through the conical skylight. Beneath the skylight floats a steel ceiling with a thin gap along the perimeter to block direct views of the sky and to reveal the walls and volume of space in reflected light and gradated shadow.
“It is precisely with an underground space that light becomes the theme. As one goes down deeper, the air, which had been active above ground, becomes thinner, and the still darkness becomes more profound. The moment light enters from above and falls on the walls shaping that darkness, space appears.” Tadao Ando
Light and View:
Views to the outside and within the museum are carefully controlled, with an increased sense of separation from the site as spaces progress from the garden into the entry, galleries, and subterranean meditation space. The only direct view to the garden is provided at the entry door, while discreet views of the sky are found in the central and south galleries. Translucent windows and indirect and reflected daylight foster a sense of mystery within a quiet, contemplative atmosphere. The sequence of spaces is organised along a circulation path with ninety-degree turns that create views to alternating cardinal directions, while the partial walls and interior apertures provide glimpses to and beyond adjacent spaces. Strategic interior views create spatial depth and interconnections between galleries that are animated by differing qualities of light and shadow.
In Michael Blackwood’s documentary film on his early work, Ando describes the activity of “light watching,” in which the movement of light and shadow is the focus of space: “If one lets light into architecture in many different and subtle ways one can enjoy light watching.”
Such is the case at the Ando Museum, where varied window forms, daylight strategies, and choreographed views create an experience of changing atmospheric qualities and patterns of light that can be considered an exhibition in its own right.
Ando is as fascinated with darkness and shadow as he is with light, as he explains: “You are able to see the light because of the darkness. Because of the darkness you felt the strong presence of light. Shadows and darkness contribute to serenity and calmness. In my opinion, the darkness creates the opportunity to think and contemplate.”
The beauty of both light and shadow are found in the changing atmospheric qualities of the Ando Museum. Depending on the season and sky conditions, the light varies dramatically from a soft, subdued, indirect, and diffuse illumination of overcast skies to dynamic patterns of sunlight animating space and surfaces on a sunny day. Gentle indirect light emanating through frosted glass windows and surface reflections is contrasted with direct daylight or sunlight from skylights, vertical slots, and triangular windows. Contrasting qualities of indirect and direct light engage and enliven the warmth of the traditional timber ceiling and post-and-beam structure as well as revealing the beauty and craft of the smooth surfaces of the contemporary concrete walls and volumes.
Light and the Art of Making:
Ando translates the exquisite craft of traditional Japanese architecture into his contemporary use of concrete, glass, and steel. Renowned for the fine finish and silky quality of concrete in his buildings, Ando’s exacting attention to detail, collaboration with skilled carpenters, and use of quality formwork have enabled him to imbue concrete with the subtle qualities of traditional materials. As he explained in an interview with Michael Blackwood: “My attitude towards concrete is to look for a kind of concrete that is closer in feeling to wood and paper. To find a beautiful and sensuous concrete.”
Ando’s interests lie in translating the best qualities and values of traditional architecture: “I think that Japanese contemporary architecture has not incorporated the good qualities of traditional Japanese culture. … I’m not talking about external things, such as form or material, but a way of thinking. What interests me most is to find a way to continue these traditional Japanese concepts and values and thereby pass them on to the next generation.”
At the Ando Museum, the juxtaposition of traditional timber frame and contemporary concrete construction heighten the beauty of both the old and new, as Ando explains: “My aim was to create a space that has a rich sense of depth despite its small size, where oppositional elements such as the past and present, wood and concrete, and light and dark clash intensely as they are superimposed against each other.”
20 Spatial, material, and luminous contrast are further fostered by the separation between the timber-frame and plaster walls of the minka and the freestanding concrete structure. The exceptional craft and material qualities of each construction tradition are independently expressed, yet remain within an intimate spatial relationship.
“Beauty is felt in traditional Japanese architecture when spaces are illuminated by small rays of light. … Nature is embodied in my architecture in the form of light … [it is] the movement of nature through space that defines architecture." Tadao Ando
Although the site and the Ando Museum are small in scale, Ando skilfully choreographs a rich conversation between the spatial, material, and luminous qualities of the old and new. Ando’s focus is on creating meaningful experiences, in which architecture is not an object, but rather a means of defining space. In an interview with Edan Corkill for the Japan Times, Ando explains his focus on space-making: “I think Japan’s contribution has been the idea that architecture is not a ‘thing’—it’s not a solid object. It’s like Kakuzo Okakura wrote in his ‘Book of Tea’ in 1906: Architecture is never a shape, it is the space enclosed by the shape, by the walls and ceiling.”
While the Ando Museum embodies a clarity and simplicity of form, structure, and materials, these tangible architectural elements are used to create a dynamic spatial and visual experience and to express the beauty of light and nature.
The Ando Museum is brought to life by light and the juxtaposition of atmospheric and spatial qualities. Ando uses the elements of structure, materials, and spatial composition to choreograph a luminous journey of discovery from the outer physical world to an inner contemplative space.